Application to certify a class action, against Champion Motors and Skoda Auto A.S. The application was filed in January 2023. According to the application, since 2021, Champion Motors has been selling new cars, Skoda model, with a faulty Travel Assist feature. The warning light on the dashboard turns on and off alternately, and the system repeats beeping advising "Lane Assist Unavailable". Even after the system is deactivated, the alerts and beeps do not stop. The companies are well aware of the problem but are not offering any solution.

The applicant demands compensation for the damages caused to the cars owners. In addition, the applicant demands the companies to repair the malfunction.

Status: Class action is pending.

Documents: Application to Certify the Class Action.

Application to certify a class action, against Health Flo, the operator of an application that tracks women's health, on behalf of users in Israel. The application was filed in January 2022. According to the application, Flo Health undertook not to transfer personal information of users to third parties. This undertaking was breached. Intimate information was transferred to third parties, which provide SDKs (software development kits) that are used in the application, Google and Facebook being amongst them. The applicant demands compensation for the users in Israel, and that Flo Health cease to transfer information, unless users' informed consent is actively given.

Status: Application to certify the class action is pending.

Documents: Application to Certify the Class Action.

Application to certify a class action against Google, filed in December 2021. Google sells advertisers two types of advertising services: Search Ads – display of ads next to Google's search results; and Display Ads – ads which appear on various web sites. Display Ads are much less valuable than Search Ads.

According to the application, Google offers advertisers to enter a Search Ads agreement, but provides them Display Ads services. The applicant demands that Google return the sums which were charged unlawfully, and cease its illegal practice.

Status: Application to certify the class action is pending.

Documents: Application to Certify the Class Action.

Application to certify a class action against Hot Mobile, a telecommunications company, filed in October 2021. The Applicant claims that Hot Mobile provides each client with a package of international call minutes, at no cost "until further notice". After some time, at a date unknown to clients at the time of contracting, the company terminates the benefit and charges for the minutes package. It does so without informing the clients in accordance with the conditions set out by law and in the license granted to the company by the Minister of Communications.

The company is required to return the amounts it charged after stopping the benefit without notifying it as required, and to cease its illegal conduct.

Status: Application to certify the class action is pending.

Documents: Application to Certify the Class Action.

Application to certify a class action, against the social network Facebook, on behalf of its users. The application was filed in April 2021. According to the application, Facebook uses the users` names, nicknames and photos, in order to promote commercial ads. This is done without receiving the users` informed consent, and therefore constitutes a violation of their right to privacy. The applicant demands that Facebook ceases this behavior and compensates the users for the damage they incurred.

Status: Application to certify the class action is pending.

Documents: Application to Certify the Class Action.

Application to certify a class action, filed in February 2021, on behalf of residents of the village Hussniyya. The Applicant claims that Bezeq, the largest communications company in Israel, breaches its obligation to provide nationwide internet coverage. According to the application, the lack of internet coverage in Hussniyya creates and exacerbates social inequalities. The claimant demands Bezeq to provide internet infrastructure to the village, and to compensate its residents.

Status: Application to certify the class action is pending.

Documents: Application to Certify the Class Action.

Application to certify a class action, filed in July 2020 against Hot Telecommunication Systems. Hot offers a  TV content streaming service named Hot Next. According to the application, the service is given to some of the clients without obtaining their consent. The Council demands a repayment of monthly fee that was charged.

Status: Application to certify the class action is pending.

Documents: Application to Certify the Class Action.

Applications to certify a class action, against eight companies which operate gambling clubs that offer group participation in lotteries held by Mifal Hapais (the Israel State Lottery). The clients pay a monthly subscription fee, the lottery tickets are purchased collectively, and the clients share the prizes. The applications were filed in May and December 2020.

According to the applications, the clubs, which are not authorized dealers of Mifal Hapais, are violating the criminal law. The council requests the court to forbid the clubs from marketing the lotteries, and to hold that the agreements with the clients are void.

The council claims that the gambling clubs mislead the clients in numerous issues. For example, the clubs do not reveal that on average, 70% of the subscription fee are not used for purchasing lottery tickets. Furthermore, the clubs state that using their services increase the chances for winning. In practice, the chances for loss increase. The clubs also do not reveal the fact that they lower the profit expectation. The council demands that the clubs compensate the clients for this misleading behavior.

Status: Applications to certify the class action are pending.

Documents: Application to Certify the Class Action, Application to Certify a Class Action Against Lotocard.

Application to certify a class action, filed in March 2020. The Applicant claims that Bezeq, the largest communications company in Israel, charges clients who did not pay their due debts, with excessive collection costs. According to the application, Bezeq charges the clients with sums which exceed the sum which was set in the applicable regulations. The applicant request repayment of the fees which were charged in excess, and that Bezeq will cease the unlawful charge.

The application was certified in March 2022.

Status: Class action is pending.

Documents: Application to Certify the Class Action, Certification Decision.

Application to certify a class action against two companies - Industrie Biomediche Insubri, a Swiss company that develops and manufactures bone grafts for dental surgeries, and Alpha Bio-Tech, an Israeli company which imports and sells the products in Israel. The Application was filed in March 2019. The applicant claims that one of the products sold to dentists in Israel, and implanted in Israeli patients, was defected and failed to solidify into bone tissue. The applicant requests compensation for the physical harm that was sustained by the Israeli patients, and compensation for all patients for failing to warn them about the potential risk of the product.

Status: Application to certify the class action is pending.

Documents: Application to Certify the Class Action, Decision Denying Motions to Dismiss.

Applications to certify class actions against the mobile carrier Golan Telecom, filed in May 2018. The applicant claim that the carrier charged the consumers with Value Added Tax, for services rendered to them while they were outside of Israel. Such charge is unwarranted. 

In Januay 2024 the parties reached a settlement agreement. According to the settlement, Golan Telecom will pay the class 60% of the VAT charge.

Status: Settlement is pending approval.

Documents: Application to Certify a Class Acion, Motion to Approve a Settlement.

Application to certify a class action against Japanauto-Israel Auto Corporation and Subaru Corporation, on behalf of purchasers of cars manufactured in 2007-2011 by Subaru Corporation. In the application, which was filed in July 2017, the applicants claim that a defect in the cars causes an excessive oil consumption and requires various repairs. The applicants request compensation for sums they where forced to pay due to the defect and an extension of the warranty period.

In January 2023 the court dismissed the application.

Our office represented the applicants, together with Shahar Cohen.

Status: Application to certify the class action was dismissed.

Documents: Application to Certify the Class Action, Final Judgement.

Application to certify a class action, on behalf of customers of the supermarket chain Bitan Wines, which was filed in November 2016. According to the application, prices at the cash register are higher than the prices which are labeled on the products. The applicant demands the company to repay sums which were unlawfully charged, and to cease this conduct.

In March 2021 the court approved a settlement. According to the settlement, the company will correct its conduct, and a court appointed supervisor will determine the sum which was unlawfully charged. The parties will agree on the sum which will be repaid, and the method of repayment.

Status: The settlement is under execution.

Documents: Application to Certify the Class Action, Motion to Approve the Settlement, Decision Approving the Settlement.

Application to certify a class action, filed in August 2016. The Applicant claims that Bezeq, the largest communications company in Israel, overcharges its customers for not paying their debts when due. According to the applicable regulations, Bezeq is allowed to charge a certain amount for failure to pay on time, and if the non-payment results from rejection of a cheque or bank's instructions – a higher amount. Bezeq charges both the base amount and the additional higher one. Under the application, Bezeq is required to return the overcharged amounts and cease this practice.

In April 2018 the class action was certified. In March 2022 the lawsuit was accepted, and the court ordered  Bezeq to cease the unlawful charge and to repay the clients.

Status: Class action was accepted.

Documents: Application to Certify the Class Action, Decision Certifying the Class Action, Award.

Application to certify a class action against Champion Motors and Volkswagen, filed in July 2015. The application was filed on behalf of purchasers of cars imported by Champion Motors and manufactured since 2008 by Volkswagen. In the application, the applicants claim that a defect in the cars causes an excessive oil consumption and requires various repairs. The applicants request compensation for sums they where forced to pay due to the defect and an extension of the warranty period.

Our office represents the applicants, together with Saber Nassar.

Status: Application to certify the class action is pending.

Documents: Application to Certify the Class Action.

Applications to certify class actions against the mobile carriers Pelephone, Cellcom and Partner. The applications were filed in July-August 2010. The applicants claim that the carriers charged the consumers with Value Added Tax, for services rendered to them while they were outside of Israel. Such charge is unwarranted. Following the application, the Tax Authority amended the rules and ceased to demand such charges. The applications were dismissed, except the application against Cellcom with regard to a certain service.

In July 2017 an extended panel of justices of the Supreme Court upheld an appeal, vacating the District Court decision. It was held that the defenses provided by the Class Action Law to state authorities do not apply to the mobile carriers, although the carriers transferred the collected tax to the tax authorities. It was further held that Value Added Tax does not apply to pre purchased communication services rendered abroad.

In August 2021 a settlement agreement was approved. According to the settlement, the court had set the compensation to the class members on 60% of the VAT charge.

Status: Settlement is being executed.

Documents: Reznik Application, Keinan Application, Sigora Bar-Nir Application, Decision Rejecting  the Applications, Notice of Appeal, Supreme Court`s Desicion in the Appeal, Motion to Approve a Settlement, Decision Approving the Settlement.

Class actions claiming that Cellcom, a leading mobile carrier, began charging its clients for transcripts detailing their activity, after providing such transcripts at no charge. The clients never agreed to pay for this service. The District Court certified the class action in the matter of Fattal, which was filed in March 2008, and a motion to appeal was dismissed. In the dismissal order, the Supreme Court issued a precedential ruling, establishing new rules with regard to the standard of review of decisions certifying class actions. Following the dismissal of the appeal in the matter of Fattal, the lawsuit was accepted, and Cellcom was ordered to return to its clients the amounts charged. Following an appeal on this award, the parties reached a settlement, under which Cellcom would return half of the amounts charged. Accordingly, Cellcom returned to the class members an amount exceeding NIS 18 million. Such return to clients on an individual basis was unprecedented, in the consumer law field.

 

In April 2015, Mr. Ben-Zion Greenberg filed an an application to certify a class action against Cellcom, following the Fattal case. The class in the Fattal case included clients of Cellcom who were illegally charged until August 2009, the month in which application was certified. Although the District Court stated in the certification decision that the charge was unlawful, Cellcom decided to raise the charge instead of cancelling it. Relying on the Fattal case, Mr. Greenberg contended that Cellcom should return the unlawful charge. Mr. Greenberg also claimed that Cellcom charged unreasonable amounts for the service, which charge is forbidden. In August 2016, the District Court certified the claim, with regard to the main cause of action - charging the clients for service they had never agreed to pay for. In January 2017, On appeal, the Supreme Court vacated the certification decision and ordered that the case will return to the District Court for further inquiry. In December 2017 the District Court certified the claim again, with regard to a part of the class period. In January 2019 the Supreme Court dismissed Cellcom`s appeal and upheld the lead plaintiff`s appeal, certrifyin the class action with regard to the whole class period.

In June 2021 a settlement was approved in the Greenberg case. According to the settlement, the clients will be repaid 68% of the amounts charged by the company.

Status: The award was fulfilled in the matter of Fattal; Settlement in the Greenberg case is under execution. 

Documents: Fattal`s application to Certify the Class Action, Decision Certifying the Class Action in the Fattal Case, Decision Dismissing the Appeal in the Fattal case; Award in the Fattal Case; Supreme Court's Decision in the Fattal case; Greenberg`s application to Certify the Class Action; Decision Certifying the Class Action in the Greenberg Case; Supreme Court`s Decision Vacating the Greenberg Case Certification Decision; Second Decision Certifying the Class Action in the Greenberg Case, Supreme Court`s Decision in the Appeals on the Second Decision in the Greenberg Case, Motion to Approve Settlement in the Greenberg Case, Final Judgement in the Greenberg Case.